Canadian government ‘lied’ over $12bn arms sale to Saudi Arabia

The Liberals’ claim they could not have cancelled the deal has been hotly disputed

Foreign minister Stéphane Dion signed export permits last Friday. Photograph: Chris Wattie/Reuters
Foreign minister Stéphane Dion signed export permits last Friday. Photograph: Chris Wattie/Reuters

Canada’s Liberal government has refused to back down in the face of growing criticism for having approved arms sales to Saudi Arabia that could help it wage war in Yemen.

A previous Conservative administration announced the US$12bn sale of light armoured vehicles in February 2014.

However, the Conservatives are now raising the alarm over the arms sale – believed to be the largest in Canadian history – while the New Democratic Party (NDP) accused the Liberals of misleading Canadians.

The Liberals have refused to cancel the sale since coming to power in November, saying it was a “done deal” that could not be broken off without possibly incurring significant penalties and job losses.

But documents released this week by the justice department in response to a lawsuit seeking to block the deal showed foreign minister Stéphane Dion signed crucial export permits only last Friday.

Canadian media published excerpts saying Dion was advised that the sale of the vehicles equipped with machine guns and anti-tank weapons would help Riyadh in its efforts at “countering instability in Yemen” and fighting the Islamic State.

In a retort to critics, Dion said Wednesday that similar weapons systems sold toSaudi Arabia since 1993 had been used responsibly.

“The best and updated information indicates that Saudi Arabia has not misused the equipment to violate human rights,” he told reporters. “Nor has the equipment been used in a manner contrary to the strategic interests of Canadaand its allies.”

But Conservative MP Tony Clement said Canada’s export controls do not require firm evidence of breaches, only an assessment of a risk of abuse.

“If the preponderance of the evidence is that it could be used against civilian populations… then the deal has to be off,” he said.

NDP leader Thomas Mulcair joined the fray saying: “The government lied to Canadians about who signed what when in the Saudi arms deal, and that is a very serious matter.”

Fighting in Yemen has killed almost 6,300 people, half of them civilians, since Saudi Arabia launched its controversial intervention against Iranian-backed Huthi rebels in March last year, the World Health Organisation has said.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *